Set in a dystopian future in which genetically engineered animals have devoured humanity, GOODNIGHT MOON is told from the perspective of a unseen, dying victim of the ravenous hordes. As he reflects on the scene with his last breaths, MOON provides a terrifying eulogy for the human race.
Margaret Wise Brown’s approach to the apocalypse is a minimalist one. Leaving only vague hints about the world in the wake of DR. MOREAU-style takeover by anthropomorphic animals, the slowly expiring narrator describes his deathbed — a seemingly normal bedroom and its mundane, but symbolically sinister furnishings.
As illustrated by Clement Hurd, the room is green (a metaphor for Earth), while a balloon the color of bright arterial blood hangs over the tableau, suggesting both a fading sun and the blood spilled across the world in humanity’s losing battle against the cunning beasts.
These elliptical clues are mere indications of the global slaughter — more-overt signs appear as the narrative unfolds. Pictures of bears sitting in chairs and of cows able to jump to extreme heights show that the animal-creatures’ emergence was not only welcomed by humanity, but, in fact, celebrated. The only explicit sign of humanity’s fate is a freakishly mutated rabbit-woman putting her rabbit child to bed in a room that was obviously once a human home; their very existence exposes the horror of the otherwise-Rockwellian scene.
As the other animals in the room run wild — cats and mice roam unchecked — mittens and socks obviously meant for humans hang on a clothes rack, never to be used in a winter the narrator will never see. These rabbit creatures have settled in, and the ravenous rabbit-child’s nightstand holds a brush that reads “Bunny” and a bowl full of “mush” that’s obviously a slurry of the narrator’s entrails.
The rabbit woman tries to hush the narrator’s dying gasps, but he manages, before the end, to say goodbye to his former possessions, to the air that once gave him life, to the “nobody” that represents Earth’s absence of humanity, and to the silent, ever-present moon, which serves as a mute witness to the genocide that unfolded under its unblinking gaze.
While GOODNIGHT MOON will inspire nightmares, it’s also a parable — a warning to any who might dabble in genetic engineering. If we don’t control the unintended consequences of science, we all might eventually be saying “goodnight moon,” and by then, there will be no escape. —Ryun Patterson





{ 43 comments… read them below or add one }
This review is hilarious. I think.
Brilliant!
Exactly what I was thinking, brilliant.
Thanks, guys.
This is priceless.
Okay, that’s it. I just deleted this site from my Bookgasm bookmark.
Seriously, though, great concept and execution. I’d suggest making this a regular column. Something like “Book Reviews by the Particularly Dense” or something.
Thanks, although that’s just a bit more dense than my normal density.
Humor
-noun
the faculty of perceiving what is amusing or comical: ‘He is completely without humor. ‘
I love you and want to have your babies.
Thanks! You’re only the second person to ever say that to me. Unfortunately, the first person to say that to me beat you by a couple of years.
And to think…I was just about to buy this for my granddaughter. Back to “Where the Wild Things Are.”
Wow–put one of my favorite books in a whole new light. I’ll never read it the same way.
/wrists
brilliant. will be sharing with my daughters posthaste.
Whatever the hell that means.
<3 Halloween.
This is brilliant stuff! Your article helped me complete an undergrad assignment dealing with literary reading. I agree with some of the above comments: this should be a feature with other books. You’d certainly attract a lot of readers with it!
Josh, I’m no professor, but I think you might be better off using sources a bit more authoritative than a Web site named “Bookgasm.” Nonetheless, I appreciate it.
Stunning. I really enjoyed it. Looking forward to your next review!
That’s really nice of you. I am, however, dismayed by the state of anonymous Internet commenting. You folks are altogether too polite.
Was expecting Dr. Seuss but Animal Farm meets I Am Legend. Cool.
Wholly enlightening and purposeful. Your insight has afforded me great understanding.
You have ENTIRELY too much time on your hands…
that’s more like it.
Wow. Way to totally ruin one of my favorite childhood books. Hopefully I can forget this soon. (But I bet that makes you happy)
I derive no happiness from your pain, but it does make me invulnerable to bullets.
Where did you get your English M.A.? If you expand it into a paper you can present it at the next MLA conference.
No MA, but we could still totally crash it if we invest some cash in elbow-patched sport coats and turtlenecks.
I think all you would need to show academic gravitas at MLA (surely that’s not an oxymoron?) would be black slacks and a black turtleneck, with appropriate button with slogan.
Might I suggest some titles for your presentation:
Plain sight re-viewing: text and illustration in graphic novels — disjunctive symbiosis or theatrical scrim?
Teasing text from pictures: an illustrative re-creation of a misperceived narrative.
Good night and Good Luck: a post-war narrative reconstructed.
The first one is the best. I’ve always wanted to say “disjunctive” and “scrim” in the same breath.
I always wondered why he says “Goodnight nobody”.
Thank you so much. I fortunately missed this book as a child, but was forced to read it to my first born. I could never explain my unease; I thought it was just the disturbing lack of symmetry in the text. But an elegy for vanquished humanity makes so much more sense.
How it came to me too, basically.
I’d love to see your take on Scuppers the Sailor Dog.
I haven’t read it, but it sounds vaguely Communist.
this is crazy…cause right now I am re-building the goodnight moon bedroom in an installation of the apocalypse…..in chicago. This world is too weird to be true.
Weird!
I read this book to my son when he was young – am torn as to whether to send him the link to your review… as a 24-year-old he will find it hilarious… but it ain’t half gonna ruin some sweet childhood memories.
Decision made. I can’t inflict this on him. (But I hope someone else will.)
No, send it to him! I’m about your son’s age, and this was my favorite book as a child, and I still thought the review was hilarious!
WAY! Way to expose the fey Foucaultian peace in the story. Its coziness belies “the rise of industrialism, capitalism, secularization, the nation-state, and its constituent forms of surveillance.” Jacques Derrida would be proud that you ‘killed’ his nemesis, his former teacher and father of “Structuralism” who turned out to be “Horrors!” gay while Jacques created “Deconstructivism” and was not only a prolific and “dominant French philosopher but also a womanizer .
Thank you very much for simultaneously destroying lots of cozy childhood memories AND confirming my new directions in literary theory! Hooray for the geniuses who discover the malevolent codes hidden under superficially benign children’s story books. I wonder how any of us survive our first ten years on this planet? Well, if we do, the trauma of narrative leads us to become twisted literary critics….
No no, thank you! I knew I was forgetting something, but your insightful comment has provided a wonderful and timely reminder: It’s time to reset my cuckoo clock.
I’m not entirely sure I find stories where humanity has been devoured by whatever race comes after as terribly horrifying. The novel (not the Will Smith Movie) “I Am Legend” never struck me as particularly scary.
I mean, really, have you _seen_ what humanity has done the to the planet?
I’d be willing to give their children a chance to do better!
I’ve seen a lot of horrible parents, with children who eventually make something decent of themselves, despite the shortcomings of their progenitors – sometimes, because they’ve learned by observing the terrible behavior of said progenitors.
Do you _honestly_ think that human beings are doing such an amazing job of handling things that we should be horrified that something they create ends up overcoming them, putting them aside, and continuing in their absence?
Okay, perhaps I’m just being mean.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=C6cxNR9ML8k
If you think this is so great, read it to your kid every night. You could wake up with a serial killer in your family. Psychosis is not cool!
Unfortunately, the only book criticism I read to my child is the NYT Sunday Book Review. Bookgasm is, unfortunately, not up to her literary tastes.